With 20 years of experience blending high-impact agency work with in-house strategic leadership, I specialize in Advancement Marketing, Communications, and Stewardship. As an independent consultant, I partner with mission-driven organizations to elevate their reputation, foster deeper alumni and donor engagement, and achieve transformative fundraising results. Subscribe to my free weekly newsletter for insights and resources designed to inform—not overwhelm.
Share
DJG Marketing Insights
Published 2 months ago • 4 min read
This week, I’m trying something new.
If you’ve read my first two issues, you’ve seen a mix of reflections, insights, tips, resources, and news. But early feedback suggests this might simply be too much.
For Issue #3, I’m experimenting with a sharper, more focused format designed to deliver the biggest impact in the shortest amount of time.
The goal? Just one big idea that can help inspire you or your organization to work a little differently.
At the end of this email, there’s a quick poll to share your preference. If you missed the earlier issues, you can find them here:
The “messy middle” of middle management gets plenty of attention—and rightfully so. These leaders are the bridge between vision and execution, strategy and action. (And frankly, they’re often the unsung heroes.)
But let’s step back for a moment.
What if the real bottleneck to success isn’t in the middle—but at the very top?
For better and worse, it all flows down.
Senior leadership teams define the vision, culture, and pace of an organization. When they’re aligned, everything flows with clarity, energy, and focus. But when they’re out of sync, the ripple effects compound into waves of inefficiency, disengagement, and frustration, slowing progress at every level.
For the last eight years, I worked in the messy middle at a large, complex university. I’ve seen firsthand how senior leadership alignment—or lack thereof—can shape an organization’s trajectory.
Here’s how weaknesses at the top impact your organization—and how to address them.
1. A Vision Isn’t Enough Without Clarity
A strong vision is table stakes, but without clear communication, it’s wasted. Teams thrive when they understand exactly how their work ladders up to larger goals.
Example Misstep: A leadership team announces a new strategic priority but provides no actionable guidance. Teams misinterpret the vision, leading to misaligned efforts.
Fix It: Build structured forums for cascading clarity—whether through all-staff meetings, manager-specific briefings, or task forces that bridge strategy and execution.
2. Culture Mirrors Leadership
People emulate what they see. If the senior team operates in silos or doesn’t model the organization’s values, cracks spread quickly.
Example Misstep: Leaders emphasize collaboration but rarely practice it themselves, reinforcing silos instead of breaking them down.
Fix It: Model the behavior you want to see. If transparency is a core value, share challenges and decision-making frameworks openly.
3. The Ripple Effect of Inconsistent Communication
When communication at the top isn’t cohesive, middle managers become interpreters instead of enablers. The result? Mixed messages, conflicting priorities, and unnecessary stress.
Example Misstep: One VP tells a team to prioritize a project, while another VP tells a different team to de-prioritize it. The mixed signals frustrate teams and create bottlenecks.
Fix It: Commit to alignment through pre-meeting syncs, shared dashboards, and concise weekly summaries that clarify organizational priorities.
4. Small Problems Become Big Waves
A senior leadership team’s inability to tackle small alignment issues early can result in larger organizational dysfunctions down the line. These issues might show up as disengaged staff, poor performance metrics, or higher turnover rates.
Example Misstep: A lack of alignment on a seemingly minor decision, like how teams should report progress, results in inefficiencies that compound over months.
Fix It: Perform quarterly “pulse checks” on alignment to ensure all senior leaders are on the same page about goals, progress, and roadblocks.
TAKE ACTION
Ask Two Key Questions:
Do all senior leaders agree on the organization’s top 3 priorities for the next 90 days?
Can each leader articulate how their team’s efforts contribute to those goals?
Observe Team Behavior:
Look for communication or collaboration breakdowns. Trace these issues back to the top to get at the root cause.
Engage Your Leadership Team:
Host a 1-hour alignment meeting to clarify messaging, address silos, and reinforce shared values.
Bringing It All Home
Senior leadership isn’t just about setting direction—it’s about clearing the path for others to succeed. Strong teams at the top lay the groundwork for middle managers and frontline employees to thrive.
I hope this week's issue inspires you to reflect on how alignment at the top might be shaping your organization’s success. When leadership gets it right, everyone benefits.
That's all for today. See you next week!
P.S. Your feedback matters. Please take a moment to answer the poll below.
I'm experimenting with a new format this week. Do you prefer this over the previous one?
P.P.S. As promised in my LinkedIn posts earlier this week, I’ve put together a list of 100 AI-Powered Prompts for advancement and nonprofit professionals. These prompts are designed to inspire creativity and efficiency. You can download the list here!
Dan Giroux, MBA Principal / Consultant DJG Marketing
Whenever you're ready, here are 3 ways I can help:
🎯 1:1 Consultation:Book a 45-minute sessionto tap into 20 years of high-impact experience. We'll tackle your most pressing strategic challenge, and you'll walk away with clarity and an action plan.
🎤 Speaking & Workshops: Looking for a speaker, podcast guest, or workshop leader to inspire your audience or team? Schedule a free discovery callto explore how I can bring fresh ideas to your organization.
🔍 Strategic Assessment: Invest in an evaluation of your team, brand, or campaign—with data-backed insights and strategic recommendations to optimize your efforts and drive results. Contact me to learn more.
Dan is an independent strategic marketing consultant helping higher education and nonprofits amplify their brands and drive meaningful engagement.
With 20 years of experience blending high-impact agency work with in-house strategic leadership, I specialize in Advancement Marketing, Communications, and Stewardship. As an independent consultant, I partner with mission-driven organizations to elevate their reputation, foster deeper alumni and donor engagement, and achieve transformative fundraising results. Subscribe to my free weekly newsletter for insights and resources designed to inform—not overwhelm.
Read more from Dan Giroux / DJG Marketing Insights
Inside the Series: Advancement Amplified - AI for IA Last November, I was invited to join Mallory Willsea for a quick podcast segment during the AMA Symposium for the Marketing of Higher Education in Las Vegas. Our conversation was meant to be short and sweet—just a few thoughts on AI adoption in advancement. But what started as an impromptu recording turned into something much bigger. That one episode sparked an idea. What if we created a mini-series dedicated to the intersection of AI and...
The Best Investment You'll Ever Make: Yourself A few people have recently reached out to me for professional advice—whether about navigating career transitions, refining their personal brand, or exploring new opportunities. And a common theme keeps coming up: career paths rarely go as planned. The destination will change. Probably a few times. Many of us build careers around institutions, believing that stability comes from tenure, loyalty, or reputation. But in higher education and the...
When the System is Broken, Everyone Loses Higher education is facing intense scrutiny and disruption—from political attacks to financial instability to public skepticism about its value. These external forces are real and putting immense pressure on institutions. While these challenges are very serious, I’ve been thinking a lot about how institutions can also be their own worst enemies: They operate in siloes. They chase prestige over people. They mistake motion for progress. (Because if the...